Wednesday, August 17, 2016

Beauty Wednesday: BoxyCharm vs. Ipsy

Hey everyone! I hope your Wednesday is going well so far! I'm going to go over a comparison between both BoxyCharm and Ipsy subscriptions! They seem to be two of the most popular subscription options out there right now, and I've used both of them so I figured I would share my own input about each one and go over which one I favor more.

Subscription boxes have definitely become a huge thing in just about every category out there! On the beauty side, the biggest competitors are BoxyCharm and Ipsy. They're both really fun and filled with some good products to try out for yourself or giveaway if you don't plan to use something.

Let's start with Ipsy since that's what I subscribed to first.

First off, I love their bags! Their little glam bags are always unique, and you can use them for makeup or pens and pencils for school. The designs are really cute and change every month! These little bags include five sample or full-sized beauty products. In my experience, I only got maybe...three full-sized products in the three months I stayed with them, which isn't bad when you get an average of one full-sized item per month. However, the five products you get are randomized from about 50 (estimating) other products. There are usually two high end sample products that you are guaranteed to get one of (50/50 chance as to which you'll get) so it's nice that they guarantee you something that should absolutely be high quality, but you will pretty much want something (or multiple things) different than what you got. You can see what you're getting before the bag ships by looking on their website, and you can see everything you're not getting that were options. Some people who show what they've received may even get more full-sized products while others will get more samples sizes. I mean, for $10, you can't expect too much, and everything you get is plenty to try out to see if you like it, but there were too many things that I wanted over the stuff I got, and I felt like the odds of me getting any of the items I really wanted weren't very high due to everything you could choose from. You can review your bag and each item and let them know if the product is something you like or not, but it still comes down to how many products that are possible for you to get...so even telling them what you prefer over something else doesn't change your chances of getting things you don't want.

Now, let's talk about BoxyCharm. This box is $21/month for four to five products, so you're already looking at spending more money...BUT...this box contains nothing but full-sized products! This includes pallets, which I didn't know until I saw Kathleen Lights unbox her July box to see that there was an Ofra Z-pallet that included six Ofra eye shadows. I'm going to stop here for a second to bring something to light...

This pallet included SIX eye shadows. Ofra eye shadow pans are $10 EACH. Out of the four products that came in the box...you've already received ONE product that's worth $60! $21 spent...and you have a $60 product...plus more. I'll let you think about that for the second you'll need to see why that's an amazing. deal. ;)

Moving on...I signed up for BoxyCharm after seeing the unboxing because I've been wanting Ofra products for a while, and the other products included looked cute. I also thought about the long run... What if I get a product or two that I will never use? Easy...collect those and use them for a giveaway or donation! July's box alone contained products that totaled up to $121 retail price. Who cares if you get one or two products you don't want when they're all great quality items that you got an amazing deal on? This month's box is actually including a liquid lipstick that's a shade I would never wear, but I know that others would love it, so I'm going to hang onto it for a possible Instagram giveaway later on down the road (like maybe when I hit 1,000 followers...hint hint LoL).

By the way...BoxyCharm sends out the same products to everyone. There may be one product that's a 50/50 chance of getting over a different one, but ultimately everyone gets the same products. There's not a huge layout of products that you have a one in a million chance of getting. I actually love that because you don't have to be like "man I wish I had gotten that over this".

On both of these subscription options, you can cancel anytime. There's no cancellation fee, and you can always resubscribe. One key note about subscribing that I want to point out here, though, is that Ipsy has a waiting list. You could be waiting for months before your subscription goes through, or you can share your referral link on social media to immediately get you off the waiting list. With BoxyCharm, there is no waiting list. When you sign up, it's an immediate process. If you cancel, there's no possibility of being on a waiting list if you resubscribe, which is also something that happens with Ipsy.

With everything said, I'm sure it's obvious that I prefer BoxyCharm over Ipsy, but they both are still great options that include a variety of products. Ipsy definitely gives you a ton of products that are possible for you to get, while BoxyCharm has a set list that you're guaranteed. You have mostly samples with Ipsy vs. full-sized with BoxyCharm, which I know some people prefer samples because they don't need the clutter of having all the full-sized products they'll never use or go through to organize. Ipsy is cheaper with a waiting list while BoxyCharm is more expensive without one. They both pretty much balance each other out, and they both have their pros and cons. It's really up to personal preference, and possible budget, as to which one you would want to go with. :)

If you would like to subscribe to BoxyCharm, you can Click Here to sign up. If you want to subscribe to Ipsy, you can Click Here.

I also recommend another subscription box that was recently brought to my attention from SolTheory. They gave me a discount code to share with everyone to get 20% off their first box. They're boxes include sunglasses, and you can choose if you want anything else with them based on which option you choose. There's a jewelry option, a beauty option (which included three full-sized products), or you can get an extra pair of sunglasses. If you just want the one pair of sunglasses, you can do that, too! The price starts at $12.99/month, and my discount code for you to use is KTPARTE. Check it out! :)

That's it for this post! I will be here again Friday! Have a great Wednesday everyone! ðŸ’‹

No comments:

Post a Comment